You’ve found a new job. You’ve had the offer, you’ve told your manager you’re leaving, and suddenly there’s a meeting in the diary where they tell you how valued you are and offer you more money to stay.
It’s flattering. Deciding whether to accept a counteroffer is also one of the most awkward decisions you’ll make in your career, because whatever you choose, somebody’s going to be disappointed.
So should you accept it? For most people, the answer depends on one question, and it isn’t how much they’ve offered you.
The question that matters most
Why did you start looking for another job in the first place?
Be honest with yourself about this, because it’s the whole decision.
If the only reason you were looking was money, and your employer has now matched or beaten the new offer, a counteroffer might genuinely solve your problem.
But for a lot of people, money isn’t really why they started looking. It’s the manager who makes every week harder than it needs to be. It’s the promotion that’s been “coming soon” for two years. It’s the feeling that nobody notices the work you do (which is more common than you’d think, and I’ve written about why being good at your job can keep you stuck), or that you’ve stopped learning anything. Money is often just the easiest thing to point to.
My view? Go back to why you started looking for another job in the first place. If it was purely about money, and your employer is now offering what you wanted, then staying might make perfect sense. But if you were unhappy with your manager, frustrated by the lack of progression or just sick of the place, is another few thousand pounds really going to change any of that? Maybe for a few months. But eventually, there’s a good chance you’ll be dealing with exactly the same frustrations that made you start looking.
What a counteroffer is actually telling you
It helps to think about it from your employer’s side.
When someone good resigns, the business suddenly has a problem. Somebody has to cover your work. Someone has to recruit your replacement, which takes time, money and a lot of the manager’s attention. Your knowledge walks out of the door with you, and the team takes a hit while a new person gets up to speed.
Compared with all of that, offering you more money is often the cheaper and easier option.
That doesn’t mean the counteroffer isn’t sincere. Your manager might genuinely value you. But it’s worth asking yourself a slightly uncomfortable question.
If they could find the money to keep you now, why couldn’t they find it before you resigned?
Sometimes there’s a perfectly reasonable answer. Pay reviews happen once a year, budgets are tight, your manager has been trying to get you a rise for months and your resignation finally gave them the leverage to push it through. But sometimes the honest answer is that nobody was paying attention until you made them. A lot of decisions about pay and progression get made in a meeting you’re not in, and resigning is often the first time some people in that room really notice you.
Questions to ask before you say yes
If you’re seriously thinking about staying, I’d want to be clear on a few things first.
What’s actually changing apart from the money? If you raised problems that made you start looking, has anyone agreed to do anything about them? A new title, a different manager, a clear path to the promotion you’ve been waiting for? Or is it just more money for the same situation?
Is the money genuinely new, or is it your next pay rise brought forward? There’s a difference between being paid what you’re worth and being given next year’s increase early to stop you leaving.
How will you be seen now? Some managers will be glad you stayed and never think about it again. Others might quietly wonder whether you’ll leave next time someone makes you an offer. You can’t control which, but it’s worth thinking about honestly before you decide.
Would you have taken the new job if they hadn’t offered anything? If the answer’s yes, that tells you quite a lot.
Be careful with the statistics
If you search for advice on counteroffers, you’ll find plenty of statistics about how many people who accept one leave within a year or two.
I’d treat those with caution unless you can see where they came from. Your situation isn’t an average. The questions above will tell you far more about whether staying is right for you than any number quoted in a blog post.
Don’t forget the other side of the table
There’s another company in this story too.
When you accepted their offer, a hiring manager stopped interviewing, turned down other candidates and probably started planning around you joining. If there was a recruiter involved, they’ve told everyone it’s done. If you take the counteroffer, all of that unravels.
That’s not a reason to take a job that isn’t right for you. But it is a reason to handle it properly. Tell them quickly, tell them yourself and be honest about why. A short, polite phone call is better than an email, and an email is far better than going quiet. You might want to work with those people one day.
If you accept
Get it in writing before you withdraw from the other job. The new salary, any change in title or responsibilities, any promise about promotion and the date it all takes effect.
Verbal promises made in the panic of a resignation meeting have a habit of becoming vaguer once the panic is over.
If you decline
Thank them, keep it simple and don’t reopen the negotiation. Something like:
“I really appreciate the offer, and I’ve genuinely enjoyed working here. But I’ve thought about it carefully and I’ve decided the new role is the right move for me.”
You don’t need to list every reason you’re leaving. Leave on good terms, work your notice properly and make it easy for people to speak well of you.
Make the decision before you resign
The best time to think about a counteroffer is before you hand your notice in.
Ask yourself now: if they offered me more to stay, would I take it? If the honest answer is yes, then maybe the conversation you need to have is about your pay, not your resignation. Resigning to get a pay rise is a risky way to negotiate, and it doesn’t always end the way people expect.
If the answer is no, you’ll walk into that meeting knowing what you’re going to say, which makes the whole thing a lot less awkward.
I’ve written a short, practical guide on exactly this situation, on how to weigh it up when your employer asks you to stay. It’s called Should You Accept a Counteroffer?, it’s £5 and it’s emailed to you as a PDF straight after you buy it.
Whatever you decide, decide it for the reason you started looking, not just for the number on the offer.
Need help with your job search?
Not sure what’s wrong with your CV?
Get your Free CV Score and see how your CV performs across 5 key areas.
Want detailed feedback on your CV?
Get my Full CV Review with unlimited reviews for 12 months.
Want me to personally review your CV?
Book a Personal Video CV Review
Just need the basics? Download my free CV Writing Guide & Template.
Job Search & Career Advice Worth Reading
Join 38,000+ professionals receiving practical recruiter insights, CV advice and interview tips every week. No recycled career clichés. Just honest advice to help you get hired.
Get My Free NewsletterYour CV for Tech Jobs: Why Tech Recruiters Keep Rejecting It
November 16, 2026 • CV Advice
How to Answer Supporting Statement Questions on Application Forms
November 16, 2026 • CV Advice
Skills-Based CVs: Why Recruiters Don’t Trust Them
November 16, 2026 • CV Advice