How to Ask for a Pay Rise (and What Happens After You Ask)

Asking is only half of it. Here's how to build your case, when to ask, and what your manager has to do once you have.

Most advice about how to ask for a pay rise focuses on the conversation. What to say, how to say it, how to sound confident.

That matters.

But it misses the bit that decides whether you actually get the money, which is what happens after you’ve asked.

Because in a lot of organisations, your manager can’t just say yes.

They have to go and convince somebody else. And if you haven’t given them what they need to do that, even a manager who completely agrees with you can come back with “not this year”.

So the real job isn’t just asking well. It’s making it easy for your manager to win the argument on your behalf.

What your manager has to do after you ask

It’s worth knowing what’s going on the other side of the conversation.

In a small business, your manager might be the person who decides. But in most medium and large organisations, pay sits inside a budget, often inside a pay band for your role, and changes usually need someone else to sign them off. That might be their boss, HR, finance, or all three.

So when you ask, your manager has to go back and make a case. They’ll be asked questions like: why this person, why now, why this amount, what happens if we say no, and can we afford it?

If all they’ve got is “they asked and I think they’re good”, that’s a weak case.

If they’ve got clear evidence of what you’ve delivered, a sense of what the market pays for your role and a specific number, it’s a much easier conversation for them to have.

That’s what you’re preparing for.

Know what the market pays before you ask

Before you set up a meeting or write an email, you need to know what people in similar roles are paid.

Look at salary benchmarks on sites like Glassdoor, LinkedIn Salary and PayScale. Look at what similar jobs are advertising. If you know recruiters in your field, ask them; they usually have a good sense of what’s realistic.

But be careful about what you’re comparing yourself with. A job title on its own doesn’t tell you much. The same title can mean very different things from one company to the next, so compare roles with similar responsibilities, not just similar names. Are you managing people? Running a budget? Covering a bigger area than the job you’re comparing with?

Location matters too. A role in central London will usually pay differently from the same role in Leeds or Cardiff, and fully remote jobs muddy things further. So does the size of the organisation. A large corporate and a 30-person business often pay very differently for what looks like the same job on paper.

Keep a note of what you find: the job, the responsibilities, the location, the size and type of company, and the salary range. You don’t need to wave it around in the meeting, but it gives you a realistic number and it stops you from either underselling yourself or asking for something that’s never going to happen.

If you want to do this properly, I’ve got a short guide on how to work out what you’re worth, which goes further than the salary websites.

Build the case from what you’ve actually done

Being good at your job isn’t enough on its own.

Plenty of people are good at their jobs and don’t get paid more. Sometimes being reliable actually works against you, which I’ve written about in why being good at your job can keep you stuck.

It helps to be clear about which kind of case you’re making, because there’s more than one good reason for a pay rise.

Sometimes it’s about what you’ve achieved. Sometimes it’s that your job has grown, and you’re now doing a lot more than the role you were hired for. And sometimes it’s simply that the market has moved and you’re being paid less than people doing the same job elsewhere. That isn’t a reward for great performance. It’s bringing your pay into line, and it’s a perfectly legitimate thing to ask for.

Often it’s a mix. Whichever it is, you need to be able to show it.

If it’s achievements, be able to show specific things you’ve delivered. Improved a process. Saved money. Brought in revenue. Taken on more responsibility than your role was hired for. Fixed something that had been broken for ages.

Wherever you can, put a number on it.

“Reduced turnaround times by 30%” is far easier for your manager to repeat to their boss than “I’ve been working really hard”.

If your role has grown, show how. What were you hired to do, and what are you doing now? If you’ve taken on the work of a more senior role, say so.

If it’s market alignment, that’s where your benchmarking comes in. Show what comparable roles are paying, and be ready to explain why they’re comparable.

And think about it from the business’s point of view. You’re not just asking for more money, you’re explaining why paying you more makes sense for them.

Pick your moment

Timing matters more than people think.

Performance reviews are an obvious moment because pay is already on the agenda. In many companies, the real decisions get made in talent review meetings around the same time, so it helps if your manager already has your case before they walk in. So is straight after a big win, when your contribution is fresh in everyone’s mind. And if you know when budgets are being set, try to have the conversation just before, not after, because once the budget’s agreed there’s often very little room to move.

Try not to ask in the middle of a crisis, a restructure or a round of cost cutting. You want your manager to be able to give it proper thought, not squeeze it in between fires.

How to actually ask

Keep it simple and direct. Ask for a meeting specifically to talk about your pay, rather than springing it on your manager at the end of a one-to-one about something else.

Then open with a bit of context, go straight to the two or three strongest things you’ve delivered, and make the ask clearly. Something like:

“Over the last year I’ve taken on the client accounts and grown retention, and I’ve been leading the team’s reporting since Sarah left. Based on what I’ve seen for similar roles, the typical range is around £X to £Y, and I’d like my salary to move into that range.”

Then stop talking.

You don’t need to fill the silence.

What happens next, and what to do about it

It isn’t always a straight yes or no.

They say yes. Brilliant. Thank them and ask when it will take effect, then make sure it’s confirmed in writing.

They offer some of it. You might get part of what you asked for now, or an increase that’s phased in over time. Sometimes that’s simply what the budget allows, and it can be a reasonable outcome. If it’s phased, get the amounts and dates confirmed in writing, and agree what happens to the rest if it’s dependent on anything.

They need time. This is the most common answer, and it’s not a no. It usually means your manager needs to go and get approval. Agree a date to pick the conversation back up, and ask whether there’s anything that would help them make the case. Then give them it.

They say no. Ask what would need to be true for the answer to be yes. Which goals, skills or results would put you in a stronger position, and when could you revisit it? Get that agreed, write it down and book the follow-up in.

If you get a no with no explanation and no path to a yes, that tells you something too.

Sometimes the honest conclusion is that the only way to get paid what you’re worth is to go somewhere that will pay it. Just make the decision deliberately, not in a sulk after a bad meeting.

Don’t resign to get a pay rise

One last thing. Resigning to force a pay rise is a risky way to negotiate.

Even if it works, it changes how people see you, and it doesn’t always work. If you want more money, ask for it directly first.

I’ve written a short, practical guide called Asking for a Pay Increase, on how to build the case, decide what to ask for and handle whatever they say. It’s £5, and it’s emailed to you as a PDF straight after you buy it.

And if the answer’s no and you decide it’s time to look elsewhere, start with your CV. You can get a free CV Score to see how it reads to a recruiter before you send it anywhere.

Either way, you’re far more likely to get a yes if you make it easy for your manager to say yes to someone else.


Need help with your job search?

Not sure what’s wrong with your CV?
Get your Free CV Score and see how your CV performs across 5 key areas.

Want detailed feedback on your CV?
Get my Full CV Review with unlimited reviews for 12 months.

Want me to personally review your CV?
Book a Personal Video CV Review

Just need the basics? Download my free CV Writing Guide & Template.


Job Search & Career Advice Worth Reading

Join 38,000+ professionals receiving practical recruiter insights, CV advice and interview tips every week. No recycled career clichés. Just honest advice to help you get hired.

Get My Free Newsletter