What to Do If You Disagree With Your Performance Review

A rating you think is unfair is hard to sit through. Here's how to respond in the meeting, what to put in writing afterwards and when it's worth taking further.

If you disagree with your performance review, the moment you find out is the worst possible time to argue about it. You’re surprised, probably hurt, and the person across the table may not even have been the only one who decided the rating. How you respond over the next few days matters almost as much as the rating itself, because it shapes how your manager sees you for the rest of the year.

In the meeting

Listen first. Ask your manager to explain the rating and the evidence behind it, and take notes. You don’t need to agree, and you don’t need to respond to every point straight away.

Ask questions rather than making counter-arguments. “Can you give me an example of where that came up?” and “What would a higher rating have looked like?” are far more useful than “That’s not fair.” They get you information, and they keep the conversation open.

If you’re caught completely off guard, it’s fine to say so calmly: “This isn’t what I expected, and I’d like some time to think about it. Could we pick it up again next week?” A short pause is far better than a defensive reaction you’ll regret.

Work out what you actually disagree with

Once you’ve had a day or two, separate the different kinds of disagreement, because they need different responses.

The facts are wrong. Your manager has missed something you delivered, or attributed a problem to you that wasn’t yours. This is the easiest to address, because you can show evidence.

The facts are right, but the judgement is harsh. You agree on what happened but not on how much it matters, or how it compares with others. This is harder, because it’s a matter of opinion, and in many organisations ratings are calibrated across teams before the meeting. Your manager may genuinely not be able to change it on their own. I’ve written about how tools like the 9-box grid are used in those discussions.

The rating doesn’t match what you’ve been told all year. If you’ve had positive feedback in every one-to-one and then a poor rating with no warning, that’s worth raising directly, because something has gone wrong with how expectations were communicated.

Put your response in writing

Most review processes let you add comments to the record. Use that space, and keep it calm, specific and short. Acknowledge what you agree with, set out where you see it differently, and give evidence. For example: “I agree the Q2 reporting was late. I’d like to note that the Q3 and Q4 reports were delivered on time after we changed the process, and that the client renewal in September came directly from the project I led.”

Write it as though someone senior who doesn’t know you will read it one day, because they might.

When to take it further

If the rating is affecting your pay, bonus or promotion prospects, and you believe it’s factually wrong or that the process wasn’t followed, most organisations have a way to appeal or raise it with HR or your manager’s manager. It’s worth using if you have clear evidence. If you think the rating is connected to something like a health condition, pregnancy, a protected characteristic or a complaint you’ve made, get proper advice, for example from ACAS.

Be realistic, though. Appeals over a judgement call rarely change much, and can make the next year harder. Often the more valuable outcome is a clear agreement with your manager about exactly what you need to do differently, and a check-in halfway through the year to see how you’re doing.

Handling disagreement, a lower rating than you expected or a complete surprise is the final section of Preparing for Your Performance Review, along with what happens before your meeting that you may never see. Worth having before next year’s review, so the conversation doesn’t start from behind.

And if this isn’t the first review that’s gone this way, it may be worth asking a bigger question: whether the problem is your performance, how it’s being seen, or whether this is the right place for you. If a poor rating arrives alongside other changes, such as being left out of things you used to be part of, it’s worth reading you’re not paranoid, you’re being managed out too. A rating is one person’s view of one year. It isn’t a verdict on your ability, however much it can feel like one in the meeting.


Need help with your job search?

Not sure what’s wrong with your CV?
Get your Free CV Score and see how your CV performs across 5 key areas.

Want detailed feedback on your CV?
Get my Full CV Review with unlimited reviews for 12 months.

Want me to personally review your CV?
Book a Personal Video CV Review

Just need the basics? Download my free CV Writing Guide & Template.


Job Search & Career Advice Worth Reading

Join 38,000+ professionals receiving practical recruiter insights, CV advice and interview tips every week. No recycled career clichés. Just honest advice to help you get hired.

Get My Free Newsletter

Should You Sign a PIP?

November 18, 2026 • Career Advice

What to Write in a Self-Assessment (With Examples)

November 18, 2026 • Career Advice

How to Say No at Work Without Damaging Your Reputation

November 18, 2026 • Career Advice