What to Write in a Self-Assessment (With Examples)

A self-assessment isn't a list of everything you did this year. Here's what your manager is actually looking for, with weak and strong examples side by side.

Most self-assessment examples you’ll find online are written for HR teams: long lists of stock phrases about “exceeding expectations” and “demonstrating strong communication skills”. They’re not much help when you’re the one staring at a blank box at eleven at night, trying to remember what you did in March. So rather than another list of phrases, here’s what a self-assessment is actually for, what your manager is looking for when they read it, and some examples of weak and strong answers side by side.

What it’s really for

By the time you fill in the form, your manager has usually formed a view of your year. In many organisations, ratings are discussed and compared across teams before your review meeting even happens, often in the meeting that decides your career while you’re not in it. So your self-assessment isn’t really a chance to make your case from scratch. It does two more useful jobs: it gives your manager an accurate record to work from, including things they may have forgotten or never seen, and it shows how you see your own performance, which tells them a lot about your judgement.

That second point is underrated. A self-assessment that says everything went brilliantly, with no awareness of what didn’t, makes a manager wary. One that’s honest, specific and balanced makes them trust everything else you’ve written.

Weak versus strong: some examples

Achievements

Weak: “I consistently delivered high-quality work and exceeded expectations across all my objectives.”

Strong: “I took over the supplier contracts in April and renegotiated the three largest, saving around £40,000 a year. The courier contract took longer than planned because of the warehouse move, so it’s carried into Q1.”

The strong version names something specific, shows the result and is honest about what slipped. You don’t need numbers for everything, but where you have them, use them.

Working with others

Weak: “I am a strong team player and communicate effectively with stakeholders.”

Strong: “I set up a fortnightly check-in with the sales team after the pricing errors in the spring. We haven’t had a pricing complaint since July, and two of the account managers now come to me directly with queries.”

Notice that it shows the skill rather than claiming it. Anyone can write “strong communicator”. Not everyone can point to what changed because of how they communicated.

Development

Weak: “I would like to continue developing my skills and take on more responsibility.”

Strong: “I’d like to lead a project end to end next year. I’ve supported three, but I haven’t owned the budget or the reporting, and that’s the gap I’d most like to close before applying for a senior role.”

The strong version is specific enough for your manager to actually do something about it.

What didn’t go well

Weak: (leaving it out entirely)

Strong: “The system migration ran six weeks late. In hindsight I didn’t flag the data issues early enough because I thought I could fix them myself. I now raise risks at the weekly meeting as soon as I see them, which is why the Q3 rollout landed on time.”

This is the section people dread, and it’s often the one that does them the most good. Owning a problem and showing what you learned is more convincing than pretending nothing went wrong, especially if your manager already knows about it.

Leading people (if you manage a team)

Weak: “I have continued to lead my team effectively and support their development.”

Strong: “Two of my team were promoted this year, and I supported Priya through the move into a team leader role. Staff turnover in the team fell from four leavers last year to one. I’m still not giving feedback as quickly as I should, which my team raised in the engagement survey, so I’ve started fortnightly one-to-ones.”

Managers are judged on what happens to their people, so show it.

An objective you missed

Weak: “Due to circumstances beyond my control, the target was not achieved.”

Strong: “I didn’t hit the new-customer target, reaching 38 against 50. Around half of the shortfall came from the product launch moving to Q4, but I also spent too long on two large prospects that didn’t convert. Next year I’d like to agree a cut-off point for pursuing any one lead.”

Explaining a miss without hiding behind circumstances is one of the clearest signs of maturity a manager can see on the form.

The figures and details in these examples are invented to show the shape. Yours should be real.

Phrases worth cutting

A few phrases appear on so many self-assessments that they’ve stopped meaning anything. “Went above and beyond”, “exceeded expectations” (unless you can show it), “team player”, “hit the ground running”, “passionate about”. If a sentence would be equally true of everyone in your team, it isn’t telling your manager anything about you. Replace it with what you actually did.

Equally, cut the apologetic padding. “I feel I may have possibly contributed to” undersells you. “I led” or “I delivered” is fine when it’s true.

How to reconstruct the year

The hardest part is usually remembering. Go back through your calendar, sent emails and any project documents month by month, and note anything you delivered, fixed, improved or led. Look at what other people thanked you for. Then group it under your objectives, keep the three or four things that mattered most, and cut the rest. A short self-assessment with strong evidence beats a long one that lists every task.

Then, before you submit it, read it as your manager would. Is anything going to surprise them? If there’s a disagreement coming, it’s far better to raise it in the conversation than to be caught out by it.

That method, reconstructing the year properly rather than listing everything, is one of the main sections of Preparing for Your Performance Review. The 16-page guide also covers your manager’s view of your year, what happens before your meeting that you may never see, and handling a lower rating than you expected, with a one-page preparation sheet. It costs £5.

A good self-assessment doesn’t need to be clever. It needs to be accurate, specific and honest, so that the person deciding your rating has the full picture. Some companies also place people on a 9-box grid using exactly this information. Plenty of people undersell themselves on the form and then wonder why the conversation didn’t reflect their year.


Need help with your job search?

Not sure what’s wrong with your CV?
Get your Free CV Score and see how your CV performs across 5 key areas.

Want detailed feedback on your CV?
Get my Full CV Review with unlimited reviews for 12 months.

Want me to personally review your CV?
Book a Personal Video CV Review

Just need the basics? Download my free CV Writing Guide & Template.


Job Search & Career Advice Worth Reading

Join 38,000+ professionals receiving practical recruiter insights, CV advice and interview tips every week. No recycled career clichés. Just honest advice to help you get hired.

Get My Free Newsletter

Should You Sign a PIP?

November 18, 2026 • Career Advice

What to Write in a Self-Assessment (With Examples)

November 18, 2026 • Career Advice

How to Say No at Work Without Damaging Your Reputation

November 18, 2026 • Career Advice